Promoting Independence Through Remote Supports for Individuals with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities: Balancing Autonomy, Privacy, and Safety
By Shaden Alsuwayh
Introduction
Independence is an important component of quality of life for individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD). It involves more than completing everyday activities without assistance; it also includes having opportunities to make personal decisions, develop practical skills, participate in the community, and exercise control over one’s living environment. For many individuals with IDD, achieving greater independence does not necessarily mean eliminating support. Rather, it means having access to the appropriate level of assistance while maintaining opportunities to make choices and participate meaningfully in everyday life.
Remote supports have emerged as one approach to making this possible. Through technologies such as two-way video communication, motion sensors, electronic reminders, emergency alert systems, and smart-home devices, individuals can access assistance without requiring a support professional to remain physically present at all times. Depending on an individual’s needs, these technologies may provide opportunities to manage daily routines, complete household activities, and request assistance when necessary.
Although remote supports offer potential benefits, their effectiveness depends on how they are introduced and used. Technology that increases monitoring without considering individual preferences may compromise privacy and autonomy. Similarly, reducing in-person assistance without ensuring that reliable support remains available may create additional safety concerns. Therefore, the goal should not simply be to replace traditional services with technology, but to identify ways in which remote supports can expand independence while respecting the rights, preferences, and well-being of individuals receiving services.
This article examines how remote supports can promote greater independence among individuals with IDD while considering the relationship between autonomy, privacy, and safety. It also explores current research, potential limitations, and considerations for developing person-centered remote-support arrangements.
Understanding Independence in the Context of Remote Supports
Independence is sometimes measured by the amount of assistance an individual requires to complete everyday activities. However, this definition does not fully capture the role of personal choice, decision-making, and control over one’s environment. An individual may require occasional assistance while still exercising considerable independence in other areas of life.
For individuals with IDD, meaningful independence may involve preparing meals, managing personal routines, maintaining relationships, participating in community activities, or making decisions about how to spend their time. The appropriate level of support will differ depending on individual abilities, preferences, and circumstances.
Remote supports can help create opportunities for these activities by making assistance available without requiring continuous physical supervision. For example, an individual who wants to prepare a meal independently may benefit from visual instructions, accessible reminders, or the ability to contact a remote support professional when assistance is needed. Another individual may use an automated reminder system to manage daily routines while retaining control over when and how tasks are completed.
Research by Tassé et al. (2020) examined the experiences of adults with IDD who used remote support services through focus groups and telephone interviews. Participants identified increased independence and a greater sense of security and safety within their homes as two principal benefits. These findings suggest that remote supports may help individuals experience greater control over their living arrangements while maintaining access to assistance.
However, independence should not be measured exclusively by reductions in staff presence or the frequency of assistance requests. Receiving fewer reminders does not necessarily mean that an individual has developed greater independence. In some circumstances, it may indicate that the available support is insufficient or difficult to access. A more meaningful assessment considers whether the individual has gained greater control over everyday decisions, developed skills, and experienced increased opportunities to participate in activities that are important to them.
This distinction is essential when evaluating remote-support services. The purpose of technology should be to expand what individuals can do and the choices available to them, rather than simply reduce the amount of direct assistance they receive.
Autonomy and the Importance of Personal Choice
Autonomy refers to an individual’s ability to make decisions about their own life and exercise control over personal choices. For individuals with IDD, opportunities to express preferences and participate in decisions about their support arrangements are essential components of person-centered care.
Remote supports may promote autonomy by allowing individuals to complete activities at their own pace, request assistance when needed, and maintain greater control over their daily routines. Unlike traditional arrangements that may involve continuous staff presence, some remote-support systems allow individuals to access assistance without having someone physically present throughout the day.
Nevertheless, the introduction of technology should not automatically be interpreted as an improvement in autonomy. If monitoring systems are selected primarily for organizational convenience or implemented without meaningful input from the individual, they may create additional restrictions rather than expand personal freedom.
The distinction between providing support and controlling an individual’s activities is particularly important. For example, an individual may benefit from receiving reminders about household responsibilities but still prefer to decide when to complete those activities. Similarly, having access to an emergency communication system does not necessarily mean that the individual should be continuously monitored.
Person-centered remote supports should therefore begin with an understanding of what the individual wants to accomplish and which forms of assistance they find beneficial. Individuals should have opportunities to learn about available technologies, express preferences, ask questions, and participate in decisions regarding their use.
Lawrason et al. (2025), in their scoping review of remote supports for individuals with intellectual disabilities living independently, emphasized the importance of individualized service delivery. Their review examined 22 studies and identified several considerations related to remote-support outcomes, implementation, and ethical concerns. The authors highlighted the importance of adapting support arrangements to individual circumstances rather than assuming that the same technologies or approaches will be appropriate for everyone.
This is particularly relevant because individuals with the same diagnosis may have very different communication abilities, sensory preferences, daily routines, and support requirements. One individual may feel comfortable using video communication, while another may prefer scheduled check-ins or a simple emergency alert device. Recognizing these differences allows organizations to select technologies that support individual goals rather than impose standardized arrangements.
Privacy, Dignity, and the Home Environment
Although remote supports can create opportunities for greater independence, they also introduce important privacy considerations. For many individuals, the home represents a personal environment where they should be able to relax, maintain relationships, and engage in everyday activities without unnecessary observation.
Remote-support technologies may involve cameras, microphones, motion sensors, location-based systems, and other devices that collect information about an individual’s activities and routines. Although these technologies may serve legitimate safety purposes, their use can become intrusive when monitoring exceeds what is necessary to address an identified support need.
Privacy concerns extend beyond the collection of information. They also involve who can access personal data, how information is stored, whether activities are recorded, and under what circumstances remote professionals can observe or contact an individual.
Friedman (2023) examined the availability and implementation of remote monitoring support services within Medicaid Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS) programs across the United States. The study analyzed service provisions during fiscal year 2021 and identified 36 different remote monitoring services across 19 Medicaid waivers in 10 states. Among the safeguards identified were informed consent requirements, data encryption, emergency backup plans, and restrictions on monitoring in private spaces.
These findings demonstrate that privacy protections are an important consideration in the development of remote-support services. However, the existence of organizational policies does not automatically guarantee that individuals experience their arrangements as respectful or appropriate.
Privacy should therefore be considered throughout the process of selecting and implementing technology. Individuals should receive accessible explanations of what devices do, what information they collect, and who has access to that information. Organizations should also consider whether a less intrusive alternative could address the same support need.
For example, if an individual requires assistance remembering to complete a household task, an automated reminder may be sufficient. Continuous video monitoring would likely be unnecessary for that particular purpose.
Respecting privacy also requires recognizing that individuals may change their preferences over time. A person may initially agree to use a particular device but later become uncomfortable with its operation or level of monitoring. These concerns should lead to meaningful discussions about possible adjustments rather than automatic assumptions that the individual does not understand their support needs.
Ultimately, privacy and independence should be viewed as interconnected considerations. Individuals are more likely to experience meaningful autonomy when their personal environments and preferences are respected.
Safety Without Unnecessary Restrictions
Safety is another important consideration when determining whether remote supports are appropriate. Individuals may encounter situations in which they require immediate assistance, including medical concerns, household hazards, unexpected emergencies, or difficulties completing everyday activities.
Remote-support technologies may help address some of these situations by providing communication systems, emergency alerts, and access to trained professionals. For example, an individual living independently may use an emergency call device to request assistance without requiring someone to remain physically present throughout the day.
However, remote supports cannot eliminate every potential risk. Internet interruptions, equipment malfunctions, missed alerts, and delayed responses may interfere with the availability of assistance. Certain situations may also require immediate in-person intervention that cannot be provided remotely.
Friedman (2023) identified emergency backup arrangements and other safety requirements among the safeguards incorporated into state Medicaid remote-support programs. These findings illustrate the importance of ensuring that remote services operate within a broader support system rather than functioning as an individual’s only source of assistance.
At the same time, safety should not be interpreted as eliminating every opportunity for risk. Everyday activities involve decision-making and the possibility of mistakes. Individuals develop confidence and practical skills through opportunities to participate in these activities, even when occasional assistance is necessary.
For example, an individual who wants to prepare meals independently may require support identifying potential kitchen hazards. However, automatically preventing the individual from cooking may unnecessarily restrict opportunities to develop practical skills. Depending on the individual’s abilities, appropriate alternatives may include accessible instructions, adapted equipment, reminders, or the ability to contact a support professional.
The objective should be to identify reasonable safeguards that address actual support needs without unnecessarily limiting personal choice.
This requires individualized consideration of an individual’s abilities, environment, preferences, and potential risks. It also requires recognizing that the appropriate level of support may change as an individual develops new skills or encounters different circumstances.
Safety and autonomy should therefore not be treated as opposing priorities. When remote supports are appropriately selected and implemented, they may allow individuals to experience greater independence while retaining access to assistance when necessary.
The Role of Individualized Implementation in Promoting Independence
The effectiveness of remote supports depends considerably on whether the technology is appropriate for the person using it. A device that is accessible and helpful for one individual may be confusing, uncomfortable, or unnecessary for another.
Lawrason et al. (2025) reviewed 22 studies examining remote support for individuals with intellectual disabilities living independently. Their findings identified positive outcomes associated with remote supports, while also emphasizing the importance of individualized implementation and addressing privacy concerns. The review included different approaches, such as mobile applications and video-based prompting and self-modeling.
Importantly, the authors noted that additional research is needed to better understand the experiences of individuals receiving remote supports and the effectiveness of different service arrangements. This limitation is important because the available evidence does not establish that all remote-support technologies produce the same outcomes or are appropriate for every individual.
A person-centered approach should therefore begin with an assessment of the individual’s goals and existing abilities. Rather than introducing technology simply because it is available, organizations should identify specific activities in which additional support could increase independence.
For instance, an individual who experiences difficulty remembering daily responsibilities may benefit from scheduled reminders. Someone who wants to feel more comfortable living independently may prefer having access to two-way communication with a remote professional. Another individual may require a combination of environmental sensors and occasional in-person assistance.
The technology should also remain adaptable. As individuals become more comfortable completing activities independently, some forms of assistance may become unnecessary. In other circumstances, additional support may be required because of changes in the individual’s needs or living environment.
Involving individuals in these decisions is essential. Family members and support professionals may provide valuable perspectives, but their involvement should complement the individual’s participation rather than automatically replace their preferences.
This approach recognizes that independence is not a fixed outcome. It is an ongoing process involving opportunities to develop skills, make decisions, and exercise greater control over everyday life.
Evaluating the Impact of Remote Supports
Determining whether remote supports are successful requires examining more than the number of devices installed or the amount of staff time reduced. Although operational measures can provide useful information, they do not necessarily demonstrate improvements in an individual’s quality of life.
Evaluation should consider whether remote supports have helped individuals achieve meaningful personal goals. This may include developing daily living skills, making more independent decisions, participating in community activities, and accessing assistance when needed.
It is equally important to consider the individual’s experience of the technology. A system may function as intended from a technical perspective while creating discomfort, frustration, or unnecessary restrictions for the person using it.
Feedback from individuals receiving services should therefore be an important part of evaluating remote-support arrangements. Where appropriate, communication accommodations should be provided to ensure that individuals can express their experiences and preferences.
Organizations should also consider whether remote supports have introduced unintended difficulties, including reduced social interaction, concerns about privacy, or challenges accessing assistance. These considerations provide a more complete understanding of whether the technology is genuinely beneficial.
The findings of Lawrason et al. (2025) reinforce the need for additional research examining the experiences and outcomes associated with remote supports. Although existing studies suggest potential benefits, the evidence base remains developing and includes different research designs and types of technology.
Future evaluations should therefore examine not only whether remote supports are available, but also how individuals experience them and whether they contribute to greater independence over time.
Conclusion
Remote supports offer promising opportunities to promote greater independence among individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. By providing access to communication systems, reminders, environmental monitoring, and assistance when needed, these technologies may allow individuals to participate more independently in everyday activities while maintaining access to appropriate support.
However, the benefits of remote supports depend on how they are designed and implemented. Greater independence should not come at the expense of privacy, personal choice, or reliable access to assistance. Similarly, safety considerations should not automatically justify unnecessary monitoring or restrictions on everyday activities.
Research by Tassé et al. (2020), Friedman (2023), and Lawrason et al. (2025) provides a foundation for understanding both the potential benefits and the considerations associated with remote-support services. Collectively, this research highlights the importance of individualized arrangements that recognize the preferences, abilities, and circumstances of the individuals receiving support.
For organizations such as 3DA, these findings reinforce the importance of viewing remote supports as a means of expanding opportunities rather than simply replacing traditional services. Technology should be selected according to individual needs, implemented with appropriate safeguards, and evaluated based on whether it contributes to meaningful improvements in everyday life.
Ultimately, independence should not be defined by how little assistance an individual receives, but by how much control they have over their own life. Remote supports are most valuable when they make assistance accessible without unnecessarily limiting personal freedom, allowing individuals with IDD to develop skills, make choices, and participate more fully in their homes and communities.
References
Friedman, C. (2023). Remote monitoring support services for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Journal of Policy and Practice in Intellectual Disabilities, 20(3), 298–307. https://doi.org/10.1111/jppi.12463
Lawrason, S., Manley, Z., Lomness, A., & Hole, R. (2025). Remote support for individuals with intellectual disabilities living independently: A scoping review. International Journal of Developmental Disabilities, 71(7), 953–970. https://doi.org/10.1080/20473869.2023.2280862
Tassé, M. J., Wagner, J. B., & Kim, M. (2020). Using technology and remote support services to promote independent living of adults with intellectual disability and related developmental disabilities. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 33(3), 640–647. https://doi.org/10.1111/jar.12709



